When Google's AI Ate Your Traffic: A Survival Guide for Business Owners

Rethinking SEO for the AI Overviews Era

You know that feeling when you finally crack the top spot on Google, pop the metaphorical champagne, and then... crickets. No clicks.

Your rankings are solid, but your traffic has fallen off a cliff. Welcome to 2025 SEO, where even position one doesn't guarantee clicks anymore.

While visibility in search may be expanding, the opportunity to earn clicks is shrinking. Analysis by Ahrefs shows that when an AI-generated summary appears in the search results, the click-through rate for the top organic listing drops by ~34.5%. Meanwhile, BrightEdge reports that despite a ~49% rise in search impressions year-over-year, overall CTRs are down about 30%.

The reason? Google's AI Overviews are answering questions right there in the Search Engine Results Page (SERP), and decision-makers aren't clicking through anymore.

If this sounds familiar, you're not alone. Zero-click searches now account for nearly 59% of all Google searches, meaning more than half of your potential clients are getting their answers without ever visiting your site (SparkToro, 2024).  

AI Overviews are changing the game, and many of us are still playing by the old rules.

The Problem Isn't Your SEO: It's That Traditional SEO Isn't Enough Anymore

Everything you learned about Traditional SEO still matters, but it's no longer sufficient. You can nail your technical SEO, nail your keyword targeting, nail your on-page optimization, and still watch AI Overviews scoop up the answer and leave you with nothing.

Traditional search engine optimization focused on ranking signals like backlinks, domain authority, and keyword density. But AI Overviews operate differently. They're looking for credible, citable sources that answer questions comprehensively.

This is where Answer Engine Optimization (AEO) comes in. While Traditional SEO asks, "how do I rank?", AEO asks, "how do I get cited?"

How You Can Get Cited in AI Overviews

Google's E-E-A-T framework (Experience, Expertise, Authoritativeness, Trustworthiness) determines whether AI systems pull from your content or your competitor's. Research from Ziptie shows that 94% of AI Overview citations come from domains in the top 10 organic search results.

So, your traditional SEO foundation still matters, but within those top 10 results, the content that gets cited has a few things in common:

They're structured for scanning, not reading.

• AI systems look for clear hierarchies, descriptive headers, and content that directly answers specific questions.

• If your content is one long wall of text with vague headers, you're making it harder for both AI and humans to extract value.

They cite their sources.

• Content that references credible data and research signals authority.

• You're building on established knowledge and connecting to the broader web of trusted information that AI systems use to validate credibility.

They demonstrate actual expertise.

• Generic, surface-level takes don't get cited.

• Content that shares unique perspectives, original research, or real-world implementation experience does.

How to Optimize for AI Overviews

Start With the Questions Your Buyers Are Actually Asking

Your buyers aren't Googling "precision machining services." They're asking:

• "How do I reduce lead times without sacrificing quality?"

• "What certifications do I need for aerospace components?"

Use tools like AnswerThePublic, AlsoAsked, or Google's "People Also Ask" boxes to map out the actual question clusters in your space. Then create content that answers those questions thoroughly.

Structure Everything Like You're Teaching Someone

• Use clear, descriptive headers that can stand alone.

• Keep paragraphs short (2-4 sentences max).

• Use bulleted or numbered lists when walking through steps.

• Bold text highlights key takeaways.

• Examples and data points illustrate abstract concepts.

Build Your Citation Game

Every substantive claim should be backed by a credible source. Link to:

• Original research and industry reports.

• Trusted platform data.

• Real case studies with implementation examples.

And create content worth citing:

• Publish original research and customer surveys.

• Analyze industry trends.

• Share detailed operational breakdowns.

Claim and Optimize Your Digital Footprint

AI Overviews aggregate information from review sites, forums, social platforms, and anywhere else your brand shows up. Make sure you're:

• Actively managing profiles on relevant platforms.

• Engaging authentically in industry forums.

• Publishing thought leadership on LinkedIn.

• Maintaining consistent business information across all platforms.

• Monitoring and responding to reviews and mentions.

Test and Learn: This Isn't Settled Yet

Nobody has completely figured this out. Set up tracking for:

• Which content appears in AI Overviews.

• What queries trigger them in your space.

• Which formats perform best.

• How your zero-click versus click-through rates trend.

The teams that'll win treat this as an ongoing experiment, not a one-time project.

What This Means for Your Content Strategy

You're not just creating content to rank anymore. You're creating content to become a trusted source in your space. The kind that AI systems cite, that buyers bookmark, that gets referenced in procurement discussions.

If you nail this, you're creating content that performs better in traditional search, converts better, gets shared more, and builds your brand. It's a higher bar, but it's also a more defensible position than trying to manipulate an algorithm.

Building Strategies That Lasts

The shift to AI Overviews is challenging. But it's pushing companies toward creating better content anyway. Content that's more helpful, more credible, and more substantive. Content that treats decision-makers like intelligent professionals who deserve honest answers.

The companies that'll thrive are the ones that stop chasing the algorithm and start building genuine authority.

Your traffic might look different. Your attribution might get messier. But if you're consistently showing up as a trusted source, you're building something more valuable than a #1 ranking. You're building a reputation that opens doors to new leads.

We help companies craft marketing strategies that are as unique as their vision. Through expert leadership, storytelling frameworks, and end-to-end execution, we create scalable ecosystems built to last. Start future-proofing your marketing for this new landscape.

You Might Be Wondering...

How do I know if my content is appearing in AI Overviews?

You can manually search for your target keywords and see if AI Overviews appear (and whether your content is cited), but that doesn't scale. Tools like SEMrush, Ahrefs, and BrightEdge are building AI Overview tracking features. You can also monitor your zero-click search rate in Google Search Console. If it's increasing while your rankings stay stable, AI Overviews might be intercepting clicks.

Should I still care about traditional SEO metrics like backlinks?

Yes. AI Overviews predominantly cite content that's already ranking well organically. Think of traditional SEO as your table stakes. It gets you into the game. AEO is what helps you win once you're there. You need both.

Isn't this just going to crater our website traffic permanently?

Not necessarily. Yes, zero-click searches are increasing, but the clicks you do get tend to be higher quality because users are clicking with more specific intent. Plus, being cited in an AI Overview still builds brand awareness and authority, even if users don't click through. The key is adjusting your KPIs to account for these new dynamics: measuring brand awareness, citation frequency, and conversion quality, not just raw traffic.

How often should we be publishing to stay competitive?

Quality trumps frequency here. One deeply researched, well-cited, comprehensively structured piece per month will outperform four surface-level posts. That said, you do need to stay active and current. Aim for a sustainable cadence that allows you to maintain high quality, whether that's weekly, biweekly, or monthly.

What if we're a small team with limited resources?

Start with your highest-value topics: the ones that drive the most qualified leads or have the highest search volume in your space. Optimize those first. Pick 3-5 cornerstone pieces, apply these AEO principles, and measure the results. Then expand from there.

‍